by Frederique Janssen-Lauret | Dec 31, 2017 | Letter of the Month
In this letter to Armstong Lewis corrects some misconceptions about his PhD supervisor Quine’s attitudes towards metaphysics and the role of D.C Williams. He also discusses tropes, states of affairs, and mereology. Quine’s Place in the History of...
by Frederique Janssen-Lauret | Nov 30, 2017 | Letter of the Month
This 1971 letter to Mondadori contains an early version of Lewis’s reply to the famous problem now known as the ‘Humphrey objection’. In the first paragraph, Lewis agrees to publish ‘Languages and Language’ in Italian. It duly came out in 1973 as...
by Frederique Janssen-Lauret | Oct 29, 2017 | Letter of the Month
Lewis here comments on two key issues: reference and methodology. In this letter, Lewis’s assesses the debate between him and Putnam about reference. Putnam had taken a pessimistic line on the question how words connect to their worldly referents. In short,...
by Frederique Janssen-Lauret | Sep 30, 2017 | Letter of the Month
In this letter David Lewis argues against Reinhardt Grossmann’s claim that logic is about states of affairs (or facts), and not about sentences or propositions. It is an interesting example of Lewis’s opposition to factualist ontologies and his steadfast...
by Helen Beebee | Aug 30, 2017 | Letter of the Month, Uncategorized
View Fullscreen This month’s letter is from September 1989, from Lewis to Richard Cartwright. In the Introduction to his Philosophical Essays (MIT Press, 1987), Cartwright takes issue with Lewis’s claim (in his own Philosophical Papers, vol. I, OUP 1983,...
by Helen Beebee | Jul 31, 2017 | Letter of the Month
This month’s letter is from 1984 and sees Lewis asking the cartoonist Roz Chast whether she will allow him to use her ‘Parallel Universes’ cartoon as the frontispiece for On the Plurality of Worlds. Chast said ‘no’ since she was about to...